About this blog

Ramblings, thoughts, facts and opinions about political things - starting point council tenant participation with my land-lord Camden council and council tenant reps plus other housing issues, and whatever.


NOTE: I believe this account has been illegally hacked. Little clues have been left for me. They like playing games.

Tuesday, 16 November 2021

Safeguarding - Hannah

Local news report about the Safeguarding review of the sad death on 9 Feb 2018, of a lady named Hannah Leonard [aged 55] who had lived in Camden in Bray Tower on the Chalcots Estate, Adelaide Road,NW3. I didn't know Hannah but I hope she is at peace now. 

 

Hannah Leonard: Murdered mother was failed by care system, report finds | Islington Tribune






http://camdennewjournal.com/article/murdered-mothers-care-failed-her-report-finds


Hannah Leonard: Murdered mother was failed by care system, report finds Hannah Leonard had been a victim of cuckooing

04 November, 2021— By Tom Foot

______________________









Hannah Leonard died after 55 knife and scissor stab wounds


A VULNERABLE woman who was brutally murdered in her flat was let down by a flawed system that failed to take responsibility for her, a report has found.

The body of Hannah Leonard, who had been a victim of “cuckooing” – when a person’s home is taken over, often by drug dealers – was discovered in February 2018 by builders who were stripping dangerous cladding off her home in Bray tower on the Chalcots estate.

She had 55 knife and scissor stab wounds and the shoe-print of her killer, a woman she had met in a pub, was found on her face.

A 40-page, in-depth adult safeguarding review has revealed how various departments “failed to share responsibility” for Ms Leonard.

The 55-year-old was suffering from an incurable disease and had become known as a “repeat caller” to the emergency services.

There had been too much focus by the NHS and local authority on her alcoholism at the “expense” of her mental health needs, the report suggested.

The system failed to piece together the jigsaw,” the report said, adding that the set-up was vulnerable to miscommunication, administrative errors and could allow a case to fall through the gaps.











Ms Leonard was traumatised by the Chalcots fire safety evacuation


The review, which was mentioned in an annual report discussed by councillors this week, has recommended social services and emergency services combine better in the future when faced with complex cases.

Ms Leonard had in 2016 fallen into a fortnightly pattern of binge drinking, depression and suicidal thoughts.

She made dozens of 999 calls, including on one night when she threatened to jump from a window of her home, leading to “a night-long deployment of emergency services and an out-of-hours GP”, the report said.

In another example, she had reported a sexual assault outside her flats and that a man was in her flat aggressively asking for sex. She also complained of chest and leg pain to paramedics.

Hannah was known to health and social care services in Camden and was a frequent caller to emergency services,” the report added.

She had a diagnosis of Huntington’s disease, recurrent depressive disorder, and was known to use alcohol.”

She had reported a series of falls at home before her death in 2018.

Despite her calls to the emergency services, the NHS and the council, she did not meet the criteria “for a social care response”, the report said.


The review specifically focuses on a flaw that can leave vulnerable people denied help, which they are legally entitled to under the Care Act, because they are also regularly intoxicated with alcohol.

The report said: “The organisational view seemed to have settled: Hannah was making decisions to drink alcohol, was making decisions about risk, and that she could therefore protect herself from the adverse effects of both.

Hannah may well have had mental capacity in relation to patterns of alcohol use and social risk-taking, however, it would appear there was sufficient concern about this to have been more fully assessed.”

Ms Leonard had grown up in the Irish care system and had been a victim of sexual abuse and childhood trauma. But the care “system” in Camden had “demonstrated a limited understanding of her adverse childhood experiences”, the report said.



In June 2017 the Chalcots tower blocks were evacuated over fire safety fears, affecting hundreds of residents.

This caused a “tremendous disruption” to Ms Leonard and may have affected her drinking and access to anti-psychotic medication, the report said.

Due to the unprecedented scale of the evacuation, Hannah’s GP surgery was unable to support her while she resided temporarily in another area,” it added.

This was a traumatic time for Hannah and may have contributed to her use of alcohol as a coping mechanism.”

A review of Ms Leonard’s death was launched in 2019. A series of recommendations were made including better training of social workers and a need “for the system to consider the whole person”.
















Lucy Casey was convicted of murder


Health, social care, and emergency services needed to work together, sharing their own experiences to offer Hannah a holistic service that was as unique as she was.”

The report said her daughter had “demonstrated compassion and understanding” throughout the process and had a “genuine wish for organisations to heed the lessons of Hannah’s cases and make changes to practice to ensure that lessons are learned”, the report said.

In a statement, the independent chair of Camden Safeguarding Adults Partnership Board, James Reilly, said: “On behalf of Camden’s Safeguarding Adults Partnership Board, I express our sincere condolences to Hannah’s daughter and family. My thanks to her for her contributions to this Safeguarding Adult Review and to the partner agencies who also participated.

Our Board appreciates the clarity of the comprehensive report and we are committed to fully considering his findings and to improving our future responses to become demonstrably more holistic, informed, proactive and integrated in keeping with the recommendations of this Safeguarding Adult Review.”


Hannah met killer in pub

LUCY Casey, from Kilburn, was convicted of murdering Hannah Leonard in 2018. The 43-year-old had met Ms Leonard in the Sir Colin Campbell pub in Kilburn High Road before going back to her home in Bray tower with a man.

After she was sentenced, Ms Leonard’s daughter Caroline Snowling said there had been a lack of professional support for her and her family following the tragedy. Ms Leonard, who was born in Cork, Ireland, moved to London in the 1980s.

Ms Snowling described her as a “true Irish lady” who was “a very strong and independent woman who loved her community”.

At the time of her mother’s death, she asked for floral tributes to be left outside her door at number 73, adding: “I know for sure that she was known in the community and loved. “She was really sentimental about things and I know she’d like them at her door.



Safeguarding Adults Partnership Board HERE

Scroll down the page to read the report Safeguarding Adults Review (SARs): 2020 - "Hannah" 


Thursday, 19 August 2021

Fires in Camden Dwellings


WORK IN PROGRESS

 I've been interested in some of the fatal fires that have happened in the London borough of Camden, before and mainly since the tragic Grenfell Tower fire [14 June 2017] in the London borough of Kensington and Chelsea. 

Cutting corners with public service provision can sometimes have severe consequences



Pre Grenfell Tower                           

  • Thursday 18 April 2013 Valerie Willis HERE - Countess Road, Kentish Town, London NW5 2XH 
  • 26 Dec 2016 John McKelvey HERE  Hawley Road, Camden Town, NW1 8AA
It was around this year [2013] that the Government made regulations HERE 
called The Coroners (Investigations) Regulations 2013 which came into force 25 July 2013 
Part 7
Action to Prevent other deaths 

More commonly known as Prevention of future deaths reports which can be found at the judiciary website linked below 


Post Grenfell Tower [Tuesday 14 June 2017 tragic fire which killed 71/2 [depending who is reporting it] people and many many others harmed/traumatized



2017

21 November 2017 

          Tuesday 21-11-2017 at 31 Daleham Gardens, Frognal and Fitzjohns ward London brough of Camden,  NW3 3BY  3BU

Landlord Camden Council 

Fire at street property house conversion 

Madeline/Magdelana Fink 35 died. 

In-depth reports on 31 Daleham Gardens Fire HERE 

Note: ward now called Frognal  Belsize


8 Dec 2017 

Jacob Sulaiman 65 died 

Robert Morton House, Alexandra Place, St Johns Wood, London NW8 0DX 

Reports HERE 



2018

3 Sept 2018 Harmood street, Haverstock ward,  HERE 

9 Nov 2018 Brassey Rd 




2019

3 Feb 2019 

Carl Thorpe 46, Highgate Mental Health Centre   HERE

Dartmouth Park Hill, London N19 5NX - 

Camden and Islington NHS Foundation Trust (candi.nhs.uk)

Strangled and set alight Highgate Mental Health Centre fire victim's aunt speaks out as Old Bailey judge slams medics | Hampstead Highgate Express (hamhigh.co.uk)


2020

4 November 2020  

Wednesday 4-11-2020  Bridgeway Street,  St Pancras and Somers Town, LB of Camden. NW1 - Landlord Camden Council   ??? 

Fire at flat in block of flats 

Henry Boddy 61 died 

In-depth reports on Bridgeway Street fire HERE


3 Nov 2020

NOTES: As reported by Richard Osley on Twitter [ see below] there was also a fire the day before [3 Nov 2020] in Kings Cross. As far as I am aware no deaths or serious injuries. 

"Birkenhead Street estate in King's Cross being evacuated after a fire. Police and firefighters have helped an elderly man out of the building and he is being treated by paramedics" 

 


14 February 2020 

Friday 14-2-2020 at flat 16 Aspen House Maitland Park Villas,  Haverstock ward, LB of Camden, NW3. Landlord Camden Council.

Fire/explosion in empty block of flats due to be demolished  

Daniel Coleman 42 died 

In-depth reports on Aspen House fire HERE

On 14 Feb 2022 there was another fire nearby 

https://www.hamhigh.co.uk/news/housing/chalk-farm-fire-sees-30-people-evacuated-8690060



Thursday 6 July 2023 

0n 6 July 2023 the London Fire Brigade and others reported: 



Footnote

Please let me know [in comments section] if any mistakes are noted and I will correct them - as and when they come to my attention. I sometimes get dates [numbers] muddled up. 


Sunday, 13 June 2021

London Building Acts: byelaws

When the council property I live in was converted (in the late 1970's) from a single house into 3 separate flats, building regulations in London where the responsibility of the local council in the form of Byelaws [Local Acts]

Statutory Instruments [secondary legislation] such as the Building Regulations 1976 HERE, did not apply to London as elsewhere in the country until the Building Act 1984. 

Some information about Local Acts HERE

HoL 1999 Housing, Quiet Enjoyment, Nuisance HERE 

"But they did not contravene the bye-laws in force at the time"


The Building Act 1984 replaced the previous system of local bye-laws with nationally applicable regulations made by the Secretary of State for the Environment.

The Building Regulations 1985 (SI 1985/1065) contained for the first time a requirement that walls and floors which separate one dwelling from another should resist the transmission of airborne and impact sound: see Part E of Schedule 1 to the Regulations.

Similar provisions are now contained in the Building Regulations 1991 (SI 1991/2768). But the regulations apply only to buildings erected or converted after they came into force."


" Byelaws are local laws made by a local council under an enabling power contained in a public general act or a local act requiring something to be done – or not done – in a specified area. They are accompanied by some sanction or penalty for their non-observance."

If validly made, byelaws have the force of law within the areas to which they apply. Generally byelaws are overseen by the relevant government department or confirming authority who has policy responsibility for the subject matter." HERE 



The Local Government Act 1972 HERE gives instructions about the making of local government bye laws [also called Local Acts]

Part XI [11]  General Provisions as to Local Authorities HERE, under the cross heading Byelaws are sections 235-238 HERE 

Sections 262 Local Acts and instruments HERE 

Going back in time 40 years or so, the London Building Act 1930 HERE came about 12 years after the end of world war 1 [1914-18] 


The whole Act came into force 1 October 1930.

        Part VI [6] Construction of Buildings sections 57 - 88

London Building Acts [Amendment] Act 1939 HERE

London County Council [General Powers] Act 1948 HERE 

Local Government Act 1972 HERE

Greater London Council [General Powers] Act 1974 HERE

Building Control Act 1966 HERE

Housing and Building Control Act 1984 HERE 
Building Act 1984 HERE



March 2018
  https://assets.grenfelltowerinquiry.org.uk/documents/Colin%20Todd%20report.pdf   

 2.17 approval under the London Building Acts and the associated bye laws was the responsibility of the Greater London Council [GLC]. 


4.1.13 The London Building Acts 1930 - 1939 gave powers for secondary legislation to be produced in the form the London Building [Constructional] Bye laws. The BLs would have comprised:


The Public Health Act 1936 HERE
section 61

Statutory Instrument 1057  HERE
1972 No 317
BUILDING AND BUILDINGS

The Building Regulations 1972




 The below Act exempted some buildings from building by-laws.

Public Health Act 1936 HERE


NB I have tried to track down the relevant local London by-laws that where supposed to be in place but no-one seems to have them: locally, [London] county hall [Mayor of London ] national archives. 

Housing Priority for Infamous Gangster

"All of which begs a question: how exactly did Britain’s most infamous gangster end up being granted his plum tenancy?"

"Camden Council this week refused to comment, insisting that its housing system ‘prioritises people in accordance with legislation’." 


 https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6684753/How-gangland-boss-Terry-Adams-amassed-fortune-one-Britains-feared-gangsters.html

8 February 2019 









Sunday, 6 June 2021

£6m Overspend by Housing Department - 2010

http://curnockstreetestate.com/2012/03/22/6m-overspend-by-housing-department/

22 March 2012 







Hanging Death on Council Estate - 2012

http://www.hamhigh.co.uk


Swiss Cottage basketball hoop hanging death

Wednesday, January 11, 2012
A man was found hanged from the frame of a basketball hoop at a Swiss Cottage sports court on this morning (Wednesday, January 11).

The man, believed to be in his 30s, was discovered shortly before 6.30am in Dobson Close estate, off Hilgrove Road, by a woman walking her dog. The body, which has not been identified, was hanging yards from a children’s playground.

Police said they requested a tent to shield the body from children.

Clearly shaken up, Natasha Ullah, 29, who discovered the body, said: “I was walking the dog this morning, I went through the park and I noticed a guy hanging on the pitch. “All I remember is seeing the guy hanging there. I was quite shocked at that. “I rang up to call the police. I didn’t really want to get any nearer to him.”

There was no sign of how the man climbed the 10 feet to the top of the hoop.
Residents of the estate said they were shocked and saddened at the death.

Muna Salaad, 34, of Hillgrave Estate, who saw the body covered in a white cloth, said: “I feel sad. It was a bit weird when I saw it. It took me a few seconds, I thought ‘Oh God there’s a body there’. It’s really sad.”

Pensioner Norma Boyle, whose flat in Farjeon House, Dobson Close, overlooks the basketball court, said: “It is dreadful. We’ve never had anything like this before. We have lived here for 51 years and never known anything like it.”

Police sealed off the area for several hours, but are not treating the death as suspicious.

The area was reopened shortly before 11am the same morning.
An inquest will be opened and adjourned at St Pancras Coroners’ Court.

Wednesday, 2 June 2021

Council fined £40,000 over death - 2009

http://www.thecnj.co.uk/camden/2009/032609/news032609_02.html Camden News - by RICHARD OSLEY Published: 26 March 2009

Barney’s death: council fined £40k at Old Bailey

‘No amount of money can represent the value of life’ – Judge

AFTER two and half years which have seen a police investigation, an inquiry by safety inspectors, a coroner’s inquest, and an appearance at Britain’s most famous criminal court, Camden Council has been ordered to pay a £40,000 fine over failings connected to the death of a scaffolder electrocuted on one of its estates. 

 The Town Hall was sentenced over a breach in health and safety legislation at the Old Bailey on Monday, admitting that it had failed to make proper checks on a defective lamp which was so faulty it had become a deathtrap. 

 Father-of-three Ralph Kennedy, 24 – better known by his boyhood nickname Barney – died almost instantly when he touched the lamp on the Mayford estate in Somers Town in September 2006. 

 The case was brought by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE), which investigated his death. Judge 

Richard Hone QC said deciding on the size of the fine was a “difficult task” but warned the technicalities of the breach had to be considered ahead of emotions. 

 The judge received victim statements from Mr Kennedy’s father – also called Ralph – and his girlfriend, Kelly Ivory, the mother of two of his children and with whom he shared a flat in Camden Town. Judge Hone QC said: “The impact statements are very moderate. The father of the deceased acknowledges that what is important is that there is no repetition of the failings in this case.” He added: 

“No amount of money can possibly represent the value of life.” Camden, which pleaded guilty to the breach, was ordered to pay £16,000 in legal costs in addition to the fine. Housing department director Michael Scorer was in court to hear the penalty and his appearance and public apology was praised by the judge. Camden has reviewed all of its light fittings in the wake of the case and spent more than £2million on inspections and improvements. But it is not the end of the case as Camden must still resolve compensation claims from Mr Kennedy’s loved ones. 

 The Old Bailey’s court number eight heard how the council did not have full records of work done to the lamp and could not say why the brown safety earth wire inside was cut. Other lights in the series of external wall lamps – only reachable by ladders and scaffolding – were also found to be faulty. Valerie Charbit, prosecuting, said: 

“There was no evidence of five-year tests as recommended by British Standard and Wiring regulations.” The earth wire, if intact, would normally remove the danger of electrocution by diverting the hazard to a fuse. Inspections showed a clear cut rather than a worn out wire, but a coroner’s inquest failed to establish why or when it had been snipped. “It has been said that it might have been done to stop the light flickering – that is the speculation,” said John Williams, defending the council. 

 Mr Williams said Camden had previously had a “good safety record” and had complied with all orders from the HSE. Mr Scorer said afterwards: “We are extremely sorry for Mr Kennedy’s tragic death. We again offer our sincere condolence to his family for their loss. 

 “The council takes the issue of health and safety extremely seriously and accepts the £40,000 fine.” He added: “Following the incident, we have worked very closely with the HSE to make the improvements recommended. In spring 2007, the council put in place a rigorous programme of electrical testing and inspection.” 

  Lawyer who won’t give up ONE of Camden’s leading lawyers has investigated the Ralph Kennedy case and believes there is still unfinished business that the council needs to address. 

 Patrick Allen, one of the founders of Hodge, Jones and Allen, now based in Euston, represents Mr Kennedy’s partner Kelly Ivory. While the council has admitted liability, the amount due in compensation is still being negotiated. 

 As revealed by the New Journal in November, those discussions took a new twist late last year when Mr Allen passed a new dossier of evidence to the council, police, a coroner and the Health and Safety Executive (HSE). It contained a meticulous record compiled by a former works inspector who, while working for the council, repeatedly flagged up warnings about amateurish electrical repairs, allegedly carried out on council estates during the 1990s. 

The patch included the Mayford estate where Mr Kennedy was electrocuted. The former council employee, Edward Whelan, said his concerns were never properly addressed by his bosses, even when he warned that somebody could be killed. He also sent his file to the HSE but no action was taken. 

 Mr Allen believes all past investigations should be reopened and a second inquest should be held in the light of the emergence of the file, claiming the documents have not been properly considered and that the council’s historic lack of action exacerbated the failings in the case. At the emergence of the file, Camden said it was reviewing the documents but it has not commented on the progress of negotiations.